mailto:uumlib@uum.edu.my 24x7 Service; AnyTime; AnyWhere

Integrating Analytical Hierarchical Process and Quadrant Matrix Analysis in a Decision Analytics Framework for Flood Management Planning

Abdullah, Mohammad Fikry and Zainol, Zurina and Mohd Fazli, Bashirah and Md Shah, Amri and Siaw, Yin Thian and Mohmad Kamal, Fazillah (2026) Integrating Analytical Hierarchical Process and Quadrant Matrix Analysis in a Decision Analytics Framework for Flood Management Planning. Journal of Computational Innovation and Analytics (JCIA), 5 (1). pp. 51-71. ISSN 2821-3408

[thumbnail of JCIA V5 N1 2026 51 71.pdf]
Preview
PDF - Published Version
Available under License Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).

Download (890kB) | Preview

Abstract

Flood management planning (FMP) requires decision analytics approaches that can prioritize multiple criteria while accounting for uncertainty in expert judgment and data availability. This study presents a decision analytics framework that integrates the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Quadrant Matrix Analysis (QMA) to identify key flood and trade-off criteria, and to develop a structural plan to support FMP decision making. Using the PESTEL framework, a refined set of 40 criteria was assessed through structured elicitation involving 10 experts from diverse disciplines. AHP was applied to find the relative importance of each criterion, while QMA mapped the criteria by both importance and certainty. The AHP results indicate that the Political, Legal, and Economic domains were the main driving criteria for FMP. At the criterion level, P1: Fair distribution of resources was ranked first (0.1917), followed by L1: Land ownership for flood protection (0.0739) and L4: International constitutional standards and guidelines (0.0543). QMA, in contrast, identified 25 “Must‑Have” criteria, primarily within the Environmental, Social, and Technological domains. A comparison of AHP and QMA outputs reveals that criterion certainty significantly affects practical applicability, even for criteria that are highly ranked in importance. By jointly considering importance and certainty, EC7: Economic loss, EC5: Financial budget, and L3: Flood Disaster Institutional emerged as "Very Highly Ranked" and "Must-Have". The framework also incorporates a structured criterion‑reflection stage, informed by the Weather Model, to refine expert evaluations. Overall, the proposed decision analytics framework enhances clarity and consistency in the selection of criteria and offers practical guidance for FMP in Malaysia and other planning contexts.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: AHP, criteria analysis, decision making, flood management planning, quadrant matrix analysis
Subjects: Q Science > Q Science (General)
Divisions: School of Computing
Depositing User: Mrs. Norazmilah Yaakub
Date Deposited: 17 Nov 2026 09:27
Last Modified: 17 Nov 2026 09:27
URI: https://repo.uum.edu.my/id/eprint/35027

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item